This article was produced as part of the Local Journalism Initiative.
Tenants at 47 Thorncliffe Park Dr. are challenging rent increases in a building they say has barely been maintained by the landlord.
“It feels unfair to be asked to pay a higher rent when the work being done doesn’t improve our daily lives, and we’re not receiving the basic services and the clean, safe and healthy housing we are paying for,” one resident wrote to The Green Line in an email on behalf of tenants who received the rent increase notice. The resident requested anonymity to avoid problems with the building management amidst ongoing legal proceedings.
In early 2024, residents in the 25-storey building owned and operated by real estate company Morguard began receiving notices of 4.24% rent increases, affecting 452 units. The high-rise is under rent control — set at 2.5% at the time by the province. (The limit is now 2.1%). In May 2024, the landlord applied to the Landlord and Tenant Board to raise rent further — making this an above-guideline rent increase or AGI.
AGIs aren’t necessarily uncommon; the same landlord, Morguard, applied for one for a tower complex just down the street earlier this year. We already explained everything you need to know about it here.
This time around, the landlord is citing capital expenditure work as the reason behind the increase. In its AGI application, Morguard listed over $1.2 million for necessary roof replacement and around $190,000 in water retrofit for conservation.
In the email to The Green Line, residents said the work done is “only what is needed to hold the building together” and highlighted issues they still face in their units.
- Tenants have reported bed bugs, cockroaches, rats and flies year after year. “Management sends someone, but the treatment is only temporary and the pests keep coming back,” the residents wrote to The Green Line.
- They also reported problems with heat and hot water. According to information available on RentSafeTO, City inspectors found the heating system isn’t in good repair throughout the building and gave the landlord until Oct. 18 to address it. It remains unresolved as of publication.
- Tenants say they also have weak water pressure and slow water flow, despite plumbing repairs.
- They say the elevators are often a problem, which is especially hard for seniors, families with children and people with mobility issues.
- Tenants also said they have security concerns and don’t feel safe or heard when they reach out to the building’s understaffed guards. One resident, who’s lived in the building for 13 years, says that at times, he’s waited 20 minutes for someone to show up and address his concerns.
- Tenants also mentioned that there is no superintendent available when they need one.
- Last but not least, tenants say the building isn’t in a good state of repair. “Walls are cracking, and the appliances are outdated. Repairs are usually only quick, temporary fixes,” tenants said. In a RentSafeTO report last month, the City found unlevel flooring in a unit’s bedroom, as well as holes in the wall and a counter, backsplash and drain board not impervious to water in a kitchen. It ordered the landlord to address these issues by Dec. 10.
In a phone interview, the resident who reached out to The Green Line said they noticed management has been working on the building’s exterior in the past four to five months. However, many issues remain unaddressed.
“They’re doing everything outside because obviously, when the inspector comes, they don’t go inside the unit, right? They just see outside of the building,” the resident said, adding that they think this is just a tactic for the building to look better before the hearing.
Morguard didn’t respond to our request for comment by the time of publication.
As of Nov. 20, the City gave 47 Thorncliffe Park Dr. a RentSafeTO score of 81% and a yellow “needs improvement” rating, with an outstanding report about repairs. This score improved in the last week from 78% after a report about inadequate heating was resolved.
The tenants are using these shortcomings as ammo to fight back against the AGI. They’ve also asked the landlord to provide receipts and invoices for the maintenance work it claims to have done to justify the increase.

📸: Yara El Murr/The Green Line.
The resident who spoke to The Green Line also questioned the logic of using expected roof replacement as justification for the AGI. “Every 40 years, the metal roof needs to be replaced. So it was on their agenda. So why are they asking us [to pay]?”
But fighting against AGIs takes time. Even though the landlord made the rent increase application two years ago, the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB) held the first hearing recently on Nov. 12. This first step, called a case management hearing, is a negotiation between the landlord and tenants to try and settle the dispute.
How tenants are responding to the AGI
When 47 Thorncliffe Park Dr. residents received the hearing notice, they decided to organize against the AGI. On Oct. 29, they reached out to Laura Anonen of the Don Valley Community Legal Services (DVCLS) for help before the hearing.
The neighbours were quick to mobilize, Anonen says. The building already had an active WhatsApp chat with more than 200 members.
“They want to show Morguard that they’re united, that they have a strong community, so they’re hoping that will pressure them to withdraw the AGI,” she told The Green Line on a call.
Anonen, who’s also a member of the Toronto Tenant Union (TTU), helped residents organize a meeting in the lobby to plan the next course of action. TTU helped flyer the building, and neighbours spread the word.
On Nov. 4, 40 tenants attended the lobby meeting, and they decided to create a formal tenant association. They selected floor captains who were responsible for knocking on doors to get tenants to sign a petition opposing the AGI. With 427 units, the petition already has 400 signatures.
At the Nov. 12 hearing, Morguard offered to increase rent by 1.25% above the guideline — for a total of 3.35% — instead of the original 1.74% extra. The tenants felt confused and considered accepting the compromise, according to Anonen.
“But they stood their ground and said no!” she told The Green Line in a text message after the hearing.
Now they await the merits hearing, or LTB hearing, where both parties can defend their arguments for the board to make a decision. No date has been set yet; Anonen says it could take months.
In the meantime, tenants hope to join forces with other tenant associations in Thorncliffe Park facing AGIs by the same landlord, Morguard. This includes the Leaside Towers at 85 and 95 Thorncliffe Park Dr., which The Green Line covered earlier this year, as well as 49 Thorncliffe Park Dr., which is heading into a case management hearing in mid-December.
TTU is supporting tenants across the neighbourhood. For now, it’s planning to have a tenant from a building that won its AGI fight speak to the tenants at 47 Thorncliffe Park Dr.
“We believe this story matters beyond our building. Many tenants across the city are facing rent increases while living in buildings that are not properly maintained,” the resident who reached out on behalf of the tenant association said.
The Green Line will be following their efforts, so stay tuned.
Fact-Check Yourself
Sources and
further reading
Don’t take our word for it — check our sources for yourself.

Join the conversation